Editing Workshop

Editing is becoming a key part of how we process and present our images. Time we spend in the darkroom is now time we spend in front of a computer.

Like taking photographs, editing is something that you have to practice regularly to remember what you have to do and how to do it. It’s complicated further because software companies are constantly changing and updating the software, making it look different and adding new features so the workflow keeps changing.  This is all great news for people selling software, books and video courses, but bad news for us!

This workshop won’t provide all the answers but will give you the tools to find the answers you need. I recall one of my tutors at university saying that when you do a technical degree the important thing is to learn how to learn – because whatever you learn will be obsolete in a few years. That’s always stuck with me and I think it is true here…

The software tools are very comprehensive these days and there can be many different ways to achieve the same goal. Each method might have its own advantages and disadvantages.

The internet is a great place to find help – I’ve previously mentioned YouTube and Skillshare – but amongst the members here at MCC we have a wealth of knowledge and experience, and tonight we are going to tap into that.

I’m no expert in any of the software – I’m pretty lazy: often I have a lot of images to edit and very little time, so I do the 20% effort that gets me 80% of the way there on most images and choose to spend more time polishing when it’s needed.

Which Software Tool is Right for Me?

Here is a comparison of all the major players in the Photography software field – take a look and find out which one might suit your needs best!

Demonstration - Andy's Workflow

This is mostly Lightroom based and looking at a recent photoshoot I did at Repton Boxing Club. I show my workflow from as-shot to a finished image, including B&W Conversion in NIK.

Before & After:

Demonstration - Robin Dodd's Workflow for Monochrome

Robin’s Youtube video is found here.

Activity One - Triptych generation

General Tips

Successful Trtyptychs incorporate images that share some theme or tell a story. Choose images connected by narrative sequence (morning to evening), color harmony (complementary or analogous palettes), subject matter (three perspectives of one location), or conceptual themes (past-present-future). Sequential storytelling particularly suits the left-to-right reading pattern, creating natural visual flow that guides viewer attention across all three panels.

Composing the overall arrangement requires care: Avoid clustering all bright or dark elements on one side—distribute visual weight evenly by alternating intensities or placing the most vibrant image in the center with calmer images flanking it. For landscape triptychs, aligning horizon lines across all three frames creates sophisticated continuity, while portrait-oriented subjects benefit from consistent eye-level positioning.

All three images should share similar lighting conditions, editing styles, and tonal ranges—mixing a bright, saturated photo with muted, desaturated images creates jarring discord. If your source photos have different exposures, use each software’s adjustment tools to harmonize them before finalizing.

Consider your border choices deliberately: white borders (2-3 pixels) provide timeless elegance against black backgrounds, colored borders can echo dominant hues within your photos for sophisticated coordination, some modern triptychs forgo individual borders entirely, relying solely on black spacing for separation when images have strong internal contrast.

Lightroom is excluded from this activity since it does not have an easy way to create Triptychs. 

Adobe Photoshop 2024-2025 offers the most comprehensive toolset for triptych creation, with precise controls and professional-grade output.

This workflow centers on creating a custom document, placing images as Smart Objects, and using layer-based editing to maintain maximum flexibility throughout the process.

Creating your canvas foundation:
  1. Launch Photoshop and press Ctrl+N (Windows) or Cmd+N (Mac) to open the New Document dialog.
  2. In the Preset Details panel on the right, enter 1400 for width and 1050 for height, ensuring the measurement dropdown displays “Pixels.” Set resolution to 300 pixels/inch for print quality or 72 for screen-only use. In the Background Contents dropdown menu, select Black to fill your canvas with the essential dark background that will create dramatic separation between your images.
Importing your photographs:

Photoshop offers two intuitive methods for bringing images onto your canvas.

  1. The drag-and-drop approach lets you arrange windows side-by-side—open your file browser alongside Photoshop, then simply drag each photo file directly onto the black canvas.
  2. Alternatively, use File > Place Embedded to browse and select images through a dialog box.

Each photo imports as a Smart Object layer, preserving full quality for resizing operations and appearing with transform handles (corner squares) ready for adjustment.

Precise sizing and arrangement:

When your first image appears with its bounding box visible, hold the Shift key while dragging a corner handle to maintain proportions during resizing.

For three equal images with 20-pixel gaps, target approximately 430 pixels wide per image. Position the first photo on the left side with about 20 pixels of black space from the canvas edge, then press Enter to confirm placement.

Repeat this process for your center and right images, maintaining consistent 20-pixel spacing between each panel by eyeballing the black gaps or using the rulers (View > Rulers) for precision.

Adding professional borders:

The stroke feature creates clean keylines around each image. Click the first image layer in the Layers panel, then hold Ctrl (Windows) or Cmd (Mac) while clicking the layer thumbnail—this creates a selection matching your photo’s exact boundaries, visible as “marching ants.”

Navigate to Edit > Stroke and set width to 2 pixels (subtle and elegant) or 3-4 pixels (more prominent).

Click the color box to select white for classic contrast against the black background. Critically, set Location to Inside so the border draws within the image edge rather than extending outward.

Apply this same process to each of the three images for consistency.

Exporting your masterpiece:

Before flattening, consider saving a layered master file via File > Save As in Photoshop format (.PSD) to preserve editing capability.

Then flatten all layers using Layer > Flatten Image to prepare for JPEG export.

Choose File > Export > Export As, select JPEG format, and set quality to 100 for maximum detail or 80-90 for a balanced file size suitable for uploading to PhotoEntry

The Expert mode is necessary as it unlocks necessary layout tools.

Activating advanced tools:

Launch Photoshop Elements and click the Photo Editor button from the home screen. Once the editor opens, locate three mode buttons at the top: Quick, Guided, and Expert. Click Expert to access the full toolset including layers, rulers, and manual positioning controls—simplified modes lack the precision needed for triptychs.

Canvas initialization:
  1. Navigate to File > New > Blank File.
  2. In the New dialog box, name your project descriptively
  3. Set Width to 1400 and Height to 1050 (confirming the unit dropdown shows pixels),
  4. Enter 300 for Resolution (maintaining pixels/inch unit),
  5. Select RGB Color mode
  6. Choose White for Background Contents—we’ll change this to black momentarily.
Black background conversion:

Elements makes background filling straightforward.

  1. Select the Paint Bucket Tool from the left toolbar (looks like a tilted bucket).
  2. Before using it, set your foreground colour to black by clicking the top-left coloured square in the toolbar’s bottom area—when the Color Picker opens, either drag the circular selector to the bottom-left corner or type #000000 in the hexadecimal field.
  3. Click anywhere on your white canvas with the Paint Bucket active to flood-fill it with black.
Photo integration method:

Elements uses a copy-paste workflow.

  1. Open your first photo via File > Open,
  2. Select the entire image with Ctrl+A (Windows) or Command+A (Mac) producing “marching ants” around edges, c
  3. Copy with Ctrl+C or Command+C,
  4. Switch back to your triptych canvas by clicking its thumbnail in the Photo Bin at the screen bottom
  5. Paste the image as a new layer using Ctrl+V or Command+V.
  6. The photo appears centered on the black canvas as a separate layer.

Repeat this sequence for your second and third photographs and your Layers panel should now display four layers: three photos plus the black Background.

Sizing and positioning
  1. Enable rulers via View > Rulers or Ctrl+R / Command+R, ensuring they display pixels (right-click a ruler and select Pixels if showing inches).
  2. Select the Move Tool (top of toolbar, four-way arrow, or press V).
  3. Click Layer 1 in the Layers panel to make it active.
  4. Go to Image > Resize, crucially uncheck “Resize all layers” to affect only the current layer, and set dimensions to approximately 426 pixels wide(calculated as (1400 – 40) ÷ 3). If “Lock aspect ratio” is checked, set height to 1010 pixels and let width auto-adjust proportionally to avoid distortion.
  5. Click the green checkmark when satisfied.
  6. Drag the resized image to the left side, leaving 20 pixels from the edge.

Repeat this resize-and-position process for Layers 2 and 3, maintaining 20-pixel gaps between each image.

Border application technique:
  1. Select your first photo layer in the Layers panel.
  2. Hold Ctrl (Windows) or Command(Mac) and click directly on the layer’s thumbnail picture (not the name)—this creates a selection precisely matching the photo’s shape.
  3. Go to Edit > Stroke (Outline) Selection. Set Width to 2 pixels, click the Color box to select white from the Color Picker, choose Inside for Location (this prevents the border from extending beyond carefully positioned edges), and click OK.
  4. Remove the selection with Select > Deselect or Ctrl+D / Command+D.

Apply identical strokes to your remaining two image layers.

Dual-format saving strategy:
  1. Preserve editability by first saving a master version: File > Save As, select Photoshop (*.PSD) format, and store it safely. This layered file allows future modifications.
  2. For your shareable JPEG, go to File > Save As again, select JPEG from the format dropdown, choose your save location, and click Save.
  3. The JPEG Options dialog appears—set quality to 10-12 on the 1-12 scale (or 80-90 if showing percentages) for high quality, choose “Baseline (Standard)” for compatibility, and click OK.
Establishing your workspace:
  1. Click File > New and set document units to Pixels in the Layout tab.
  2. Enter 1400 for page width and 1050 for page height.
  3. Set DPI to 300 for versatile print/screen use.
  4. Select RGB/8 color format for standard photography work, and choose sRGB IEC61966-2.1 color profile to ensure consistent colour display across devices.
  5. Create a custom preset by clicking the plus icon before finalizing—name it “Triptych 1400×1050” for instant reuse in future projects.
Black background implementation:
  1. Select the Flood Fill Tool (paint bucket icon) from the left Tools panel.
  2. In the Color Panel on the right, navigate to the Greyscale tab and move the slider completely left to 0% for pure black, or manually set all RGB values to zero in the RGB tab.
  3. Click anywhere on your white canvas with the Flood Fill Tool active to instantly transform the entire background to black.
Image placement and arrangement:
  1. Use File > Place to import each of your three photographs.
  2. A file browser opens—select your first image and click Open.
  3. Your cursor becomes a crosshair with a small preview. Click-drag diagonally to place the image, though precise sizing comes next.
  4. Repeat this placement process for images two and three.
  5. Each placed image becomes a separate layer visible in the Layers Panel on the right side.
Mathematical precision for spacing
  1. Enable snapping by clicking the magnet icon in the top toolbar—this helps images align cleanly.
  2. With the Move Tool selected (press V), select each image layer and resize by dragging corner handles.
  3. For 1400 pixels width with 20-pixel spacing: (1400 – 40) ÷ 3 = approximately 453 pixels per image.
  4. Affinity Photo automatically maintains proportions when resizing from corners.
  5. Position the left image flush with the canvas edge, the center image 20 pixels from the left image’s right edge, and the right image 20 pixels from the center with 20 pixels remaining at the canvas right edge. Use arrow keys for single-pixel nudges to achieve perfection.
Layer effects for borders:
  1. Select the first image layer in the Layers Panel and click the FX icon (stylised “fx” in a circle) at the panel’s bottom.
  2. In the Layer Effects panel that opens, check Outline from the left list. Set Radius to 2-3 pixels for border thickness, Alignment to Inside (crucial for keeping borders within image boundaries), Fill Style to Solid Colour, and click the colour swatch to choose white.
  3. This non-destructive approach means borders remain editable. Apply identical settings to your second and third image layers.
Export workflow:

Affinity Photo distinguishes between saving editable projects and exporting finished images.

Before exporting, save your work via File > Save As in .afphoto format to preserve all layers.

For JPEG export, use File > Export (not Save)—this critical distinction trips up many new users. Select JPEG format, set quality to 90-95% for the sweet spot between file size and visual quality, confirm dimensions show 1400 x 1050, and ensure color space displays sRGB. The Export function flattens all layers automatically while your original layered file remains intact.

Apple Photos cannot create triptychs natively

The older iPhoto application offered basic collage templates, but Photos removed this functionality entirely. Apple Pages provides the workaround solution, offering precise layout control using free macOS software.

Exporting photos for external use:

Open Photos and select your three desired images by clicking each while holding Command.

  1. Navigate to File > Export > Export 3 Photos,
  2. Set Photo Kind to JPEG, Quality to Maximum, and Size to Full Size.
  3. Export the files to an easily accessible location like your Desktop or a dedicated Triptych Project folder—this creates standalone files that Pages can access, since Photos keeps images locked within its protected library structure.
Pages document foundation:
  1. Launch Pages (via Applications folder or Spotlight: Command-Space, type “Pages”).
  2. Select the Blank template from the Basic category and click Create.
  3. Immediately convert to page layout mode via File > Convert to Page Layout—this critical step removes text flow constraints and enables pixel-perfect element positioning anywhere on the canvas.
Custom dimension setup:
  1. Click File > Page Setup, then the Paper Size dropdown.
  2. Select Manage Custom Sizes and click the + button to create a new size.
  3. Name it “Triptych Canvas” and enter dimensions of Width: 4.861 inches and Height: 3.646 inches (these equal 1400×1050 pixels at 288 DPI, the standard for retina displays).
  4. Set all margins to 0 (zero) for edge-to-edge design capability.

This is necessary because Pages operates in physical units rather than pixels.

Black background application:
  1. Click anywhere on the blank canvas (not on objects),
  2. Ensure the Format sidebar is visible (if not, click Format in the top-right toolbar),
  3. Locate the Background section, select Colour Fill from the dropdown, and click the colour swatch.
  4. In the colour picker, drag the brightness slider completely down or set all RGB values to zero for pure black.
Calculated image placement:
  1. For three equal images with 20-pixel spacing, each image should be 1.574 inches wide × 3.646 inches tall (converting 453×1050 pixels to inches at 288 DPI).
  2. The spacing between images is 0.069 inches(20 pixels converted).
  3. Click the Shape button in the toolbar, select Rectangle, and in the Format sidebar’s Arrange tab, set Width to 1.574 and Height to 3.646.
  4. Position this first shape at X: 0, Y: 0 (top-left).
  5. Copy-paste this rectangle twice, positioning the second at X: 1.643 (1.574 + 0.069) and the third at X: 3.286 (accounting for two image widths plus two gaps).
Image insertion via drag and drop

Use macOS split screen (Option-click green window button) to display Finder with your exported photos alongside Pages.

For each rectangle, select it in Pages, go to Format sidebar > Style tab, set Fill to No Fill and Border to Line with width 1-2 points in white (creating your keyline border).

Drag each photo from Finder directly into its corresponding rectangle in Pages—the image fills the shape automatically.

Double-click any image to enter mask editing mode, allowing you to reposition or zoom the photo within its frame without changing the frame size.

JPEG export via Preview

Pages doesn’t offer direct JPEG export, requiring a two-step process.

  1. Click File > Print, then click the PDF dropdown in the bottom-left corner and select Open PDF in Preview.  The triptych opens in Preview automatically.
  2. From Preview, click File > Export, set Format to JPEG, Resolution to 300 pixels/inch for high quality, drag the Quality slider to maximum, and save.

This print-to-PDF-to-JPEG workflow produces sharper results than Pages’ direct image export for photographic content.

Canvas initialization:
  1. Launch PaintShop Pro and press Ctrl+N or go to File > New.
  2. In the New Image dialog, set Width to 1400 and Height to 1050 with Units set to Pixels.
  3. Leave Resolution at default (72).
  4. Select Raster Background for photo collage work and RGB – 8 bits/channel for standard colour depth.
  5. Click the Color box to open the color picker, select black (RGB values 0,0,0 or hex #000000), and click OK to create your canvas.
Alternative background filling

If you created a white canvas, select the Flood Fill Tool (paint bucket icon) from the Tools toolbar. In the Materials palette (right side), click the Foreground color box and select black. Click anywhere on your canvas to fill it completely with black—this approach is simpler than recreating the entire canvas.

Multi-image import process
  1. Use File > Open (Ctrl+O) to browse for your first photo.
  2. When it opens in its own window, select all with Ctrl+A and copy with Ctrl+C.
  3. Click back to your main triptych canvas tab, then paste as a new layer using Edit > Paste As New Layer (Ctrl+L).
  4. The photo appears on the canvas as a separate layer visible in the Layers palette (press F8 if not visible).
  5. Repeat this open-copy-paste sequence for your second and third photographs, creating distinct layers for each.
Individual layer resizing:
  1. In the Layers palette, click the layer you want to resize. Go to Image > Resize (Shift+S) and critically uncheck “Resize all layers”—failing this step resizes everything simultaneously.
  2. For three images with spacing: (1400 – 40) ÷ 3 = approximately 453 pixels width. Set height to 1010 pixels with “Lock aspect ratio” checked to maintain proportions (resulting width may vary slightly—this is acceptable). Select Bicubic resample method for quality.
  3. Repeat for each of the three image layers individually.
Positioning with the Pick Tool
  1. Select the Pick Tool (top of toolbar, arrow with cross, or press K).
  2. In the Layers palette, click the layer to position.
  3. Click-drag the image to move it – place the first image on the left with 20 pixels from the edge, the second in the centre with 20-pixel gaps on both sides, and the third on the right. Use keyboard arrow keys for single-pixel precision adjustments. The View > Grid option provides visual guidance for alignment.
Border creation workflow

PaintShop Pro’s individual image borders require a fairly complex multi-step approach.

  1. Select the Magic Wand tool, click on your first photo to select it (producing “marching ants”)
  2. Go to Selections > Modify > Expand and enter 2-3 pixels.
  3. Press Ctrl+Shift+I to invert the selection.
  4. Create a new layer via Layers > New Raster Layer, set your foreground colour to white in the Materials palette, and fill the selection with Edit > Fill (Shift+F) choosing Foreground colour.
  5. Deselect with Ctrl+Shift+D. This creates a border layer.
  6. Repeat for each image—while complex for beginners, it provides ultimate control.
Dual-format preservation
  1. Save your layered master first: File > Save As, select PaintShop Pro Image (*.pspimage) format, name it “Triptych_Master,” and save for future editability.
  2. For JPEG export, use File > Save As again, select JPEG format, choose your location, and click Save. In the JPEG Save Options dialog, set compression factor to 10-20 (lower numbers mean higher quality—counterintuitive but accurate), select Standard encoding, and click OK. Confirm “Yes” when asked about flattening layers—JPEG format requires merging all layers into one flat image.
Project initialisation:
  1. Launch GIMP and press Ctrl+N (Windows/Linux) or Cmd+N (Mac), or go to File > New. The Create a New Image dialog appears.
  2. In the Image Size section, enter 1400 for Width and 1050 for Height, verifying the unit dropdown shows px (pixels). Before clicking OK, ensure your foreground colour in the Toolbox (lower left, top coloured square) is black—if not, click it to open the colour picker, drag the slider left to pure black, and confirm.
  3. Still in the Create a New Image dialog, scroll to the Fill with section.
  4. Click the dropdown (probably showing “White”) and select Foreground colour—since you set foreground to black in the previous step, your canvas will fill with black upon creation.
  5. Click OK to generate your canvas.
Batch image import:
  1. Go to File > Open as Layers rather than regular Open—this distinction is crucial.
  2. In the file browser, click your first image, then hold Ctrl (Windows/Linux) or Cmd (Mac) and click your second and third images to select all three simultaneously.
  3. Click Open to import all three as separate layers stacked on your black background.
  4. The Layers panel (right side, or Windows > Dockable Dialogs > Layers if hidden) displays all four layers: three photos plus black background.
Proportional resizing:
  1. Click the first image layer in the Layers panel to select it.
  2. Press Shift+S or select the Scale Tool from the Toolbox.
  3. Click anywhere on the image to open the Scale Layer dialog.
  4. The chain icon between Width and Height controls proportional scaling—keep it linked (closed) to maintain aspect ratio.
  5. For triptych sizing: (1400 – 40 borders – 40 spacing) ÷ 3 = approximately 453 pixels wide by 700-1000 pixels tall. Enter dimensions and click Scale to confirm.
  6. Repeat for each of the three image layers.
Layer positioning controls:
  1. Select the Move Tool (press M or click the cross-with-arrows icon).
  2. Ensure the correct layer is selected in the Layers panel, then click-drag the image on the canvas to position it.
  3. Place the first image on the left with approximately 25 pixels black border from the edge, the second in the center with 20-pixel gaps on both sides, and the third on the right with consistent spacing.
  4. Use keyboard arrow keys for single-pixel precision—this tactile control proves essential for achieving professional alignment.
Stroke selection for borders:
  1. In the Layers panel, click your first image layer.
  2. Go to Select > All (Ctrl+A / Cmd+A) to select the entire layer—”marching ants” appear around edges.
  3. Navigate to Edit > Stroke Selection to open the stroke dialog.
  4. Set Line width to 2-3 pixels for subtle borders, ensure Stroke line is selected, click the Color box to choose white or your preferred border color, and click Stroke to apply.
  5. The stroke centers on the selection edge, meaning half appears inside your image and half outside—for a border completely outside the image, use Select > Shrink by half your desired width before stroking.
  6. Complete the border by going to Select > None (Shift+Ctrl+A / Shift+Cmd+A).
  7. Repeat this entire sequence for your second and third image layers, maintaining identical settings.
Flatten and export procedure:
  1. Before flattening, consider saving a layered version via File > Save As in GIMP’s native .XCF format to preserve editing capability.
  2. When ready for final export, go to Image > Flatten Image to merge all layers into one.
  3. For JPEG export, use File > Export As (Shift+Ctrl+E / Shift+Cmd+E)—never use “Save” which only creates .XCF files.
  4. Type your filename ending in .jpg or .jpeg to set the format, choose your destination, and click Export.
  5. The JPEG export dialog appears with a Quality slider—set to 90-95 for optimal balance between quality and file size, or 95-100 for archival/print purposes. Check “Show preview in image window” to see compression effects in real-time. Confirm Optimize and Progressive are checked, then click Export to finalize.

Canva’s 2024-2025 web interface revolutionizes triptych creation for non-technical users, requiring zero software installation while delivering professional results. The browser-based platform’s intuitive drag-and-drop interface makes it the most accessible option for beginners, though advanced users may find layer controls less sophisticated than desktop alternatives.

This workflow should be compatible with the Free level of Canva

Custom dimension setup:
  1. Log into Canva at www.canva.com and click the purple Create a design button in the top-right corner.
  2. In the dropdown menu, select Custom size (marked with a resize icon). In the popup that appears, enter 1400 for width and 1050 for height, ensuring the unit dropdown displays px (pixels)—change from “in” or “cm” if necessary.
  3. Click Create new design to open your custom canvas in the Canva editor.

Background colour:

Your new canvas opens with a white background.

  1. Click anywhere on the white area (avoiding any elements) to select the entire canvas.
  2. In the toolbar directly above your design, locate the Background colour square (shows white initially).
  3. Click this square to open the colour palette panel on the left. At the top of this panel, color swatches display common colours—click the black tile (usually top row) to instantly change your canvas to black.
  4. Alternatively, use the hex code method: find the field showing “#FFFFFF” and type #000000 for pure black.
Photo upload methods:
  1. On the left sidebar, click Uploads (upward arrow icon) to expand the uploads panel.
  2. Click the purple Upload files button and browse to your photos—select all three by holding Ctrl (Windows) or Cmd (Mac) while clicking, then click Open to upload simultaneously.
  3. Alternatively, drag image files directly from your computer’s file browser into the Canva editor window.
  4. Uploaded images appear in the Uploads panel as thumbnails, ready for placement.
Image placement and sizing:
  1. From the Uploads panel, click-drag your first image onto the black canvas and release to drop it.
  2. Repeat for your second and third images.
  3. Don’t worry about positioning yet—just get all three on the canvas.
  4. To resize, click an image to select it (white corner handles appear).
  5. For precise dimensions matching the triptych requirements, unlock the aspect ratio by clicking the lock icon in the top toolbar, then type 453 for width and 1050 for height in the dimension fields. Press Enter to apply.
  6. Repeat this exact sizing for all three images to ensure consistency.
Mathematical spacing:
  1. For 1400 pixels with 20-pixel gaps: (1400 – 40) ÷ 3 = 453 pixels per image.
  2. Position your first image flush with the canvas left edge (X position = 0).
  3. The second image should start at 473 pixelsfrom the left (453 + 20 spacing).
  4. The third image starts at 946 pixels from the left (453 + 20 + 453 + 20).
  5. Canva displays blue and pink guide lines as you drag elements—these “smart guides” appear when objects are evenly spaced or aligned, providing visual confirmation of proper positioning.
  6. For easier spacing, select all three images (click first, hold Shift, click others), click Position in the top toolbar, and choose Tidy up for automatic distribution—then fine-tune with arrow keys.
Border application options:
  1. Click your first image to select it.
  2. In the toolbar above the canvas, find and click the Border style icon (square with thick outline, possibly under the three-dot menu).
  3. A panel opens with border options: set Weight to 2-3 for subtle elegance or 5-10 for bold impact, click the Color tile and select white for classic contrast against black, and leave corner rounding at 0 for sharp edges.
  4. The border applies instantly.

Repeat this process for your second and third images, using identical settings for visual consistency.

JPEG export workflow:
  1. Click the Share button in the top-right corner (may show an upward arrow icon).
  2. In the dropdown menu, select Download.
  3. The download options panel appears—click the File type dropdown and select JPG(identical to JPEG).
  4. Keep “Current page” selected unless working with multi-page documents.
  5. If quality settings appear, drag the slider to maximum for best results.
  6. Click the purple Download button at the panel’s bottom.
  7. Canva processes your file and automatically downloads it to your computer’s Downloads folder.
  8. To rename before downloading, click the design name at the very top of the editor and type a new name like “My-Triptych-2024″—this becomes the downloaded filename.

Activity Two - Complex Selections and masks

For Activity Two we will begin by watching a demonstration of state of the art AI based selection and masking in Photoshop 2026

https://youtu.be/mwfMaLz3taY

Features like this are great news!  It is otherwise a complex job…

Manual Subject Selection with Complex Hair Detail: Complete Multi-Software Guide

Master the art of selecting subjects with intricate hair using proven manual techniques that don’t rely on AI tools. This comprehensive guide covers channel-based selection methods—the professional standard for capturing every strand of flyaway hair—across five powerful photo editing programs, plus background adjustment techniques in Lightroom.

The channel-based method revolutionizes difficult selections by exploiting the color information already present in your images. Rather than painstakingly tracing edges, you leverage the natural contrast between your subject and background within individual color channels (Red, Green, Blue). This technique consistently delivers superior results for hair, fur, trees, and any subject with fine, complex edges—results that often surpass even modern AI tools when executed properly.

Understanding the Channel-Based Selection Philosophy

Before diving into software-specific instructions, grasp the fundamental principle: every color image comprises separate channels of information. An RGB image contains three grayscale representations—one for red data, one for green, one for blue. When you view the “normal” color image, you’re seeing these three channels combined. By examining channels individually, you often discover one channel where the subject appears dramatically darker or lighter than the background. This contrast difference becomes your selection blueprint.

Why this works for hair: Individual strands barely visible in the full color image often appear starkly defined in a single channel. A blonde person against a blue sky might show little contrast in the combined image, but in the Blue channel alone, their hair appears nearly white against a darker sky. This contrast—invisible to casual observation—provides the selection precision needed to capture every wispy strand.

The workflow principle: Find the highest-contrast channel, duplicate it, enhance that contrast further using adjustment curves, paint the subject completely black (or white), then convert this refined grayscale information into a selection. The result captures hair detail that would require hours of manual tracing.

Corel PaintShop Pro: Smart Selection and Refine Brush

PaintShop Pro doesn’t expose raw color channels as directly as Photoshop/GIMP, but provides the powerful Refine Brush tool specifically designed for complex hair selections.

Initial Subject Selection

Step 1: Open Image and Start Selection

  • Launch PaintShop Pro and File > Open your image
  • Click Smart Selection Brush from Selection Tools flyout menu (magic wand with brush icon, or press Srepeatedly to cycle to it)
  • What this tool does: Intelligently selects based on color/luminance as you paint, expanding to detected edges
  • In Tool Options, set Tolerance to 20-40 (lower for distinct subject/background color difference, higher for similar)
  • Set Smart Edge checkbox ON for automatic edge detection
  • Set Mode to Add (default)

Step 2: Roughly Select Subject

  • Click-drag brush across subject’s body, painting broad strokes
  • Selection expands automatically to detected edges (marching ants appear)
  • Paint across face, hair, clothing until most of subject selected
  • Don’t worry about fine hair edges yet—rough selection suffices for now
  • Hold Ctrl while painting to temporarily switch to Remove mode if selection expands into background
  • Result: Approximate selection captures majority of subject

Refining with Refine Brush Tool

Step 3: Activate Refine Brush

  • With selection active, go to Selections > Refine Brush (or click Refine Brush button in toolbar if visible)
  • What opens: Refine Brush dialog with preview window
  • Image displays with your selection visible against chosen background (overlay by default)
  • What this tool does: Specialized refinement specifically for complex edges like hair, using advanced algorithms

Step 4: Choose Preview Background

  • In Preview drop-down (within Refine Brush dialog), select viewing mode:
  • Overlay (default): Red overlay on unselected areas, clear selected areas—good for seeing rough boundaries
  • Black: Subject on black background—excellent for revealing edge problems with light-haired subjects
  • White: Subject on white background—excellent for dark-haired subjects
  • Black & White: Shows actual mask—white=selected, black=unselected, gray=partial
  • Toggle between views while refining to catch different edge issues

Step 5: Refine Edges with Brush Modes

  • Tool Options show Brush Mode dropdown with four options:
  • Refine mode (default): Intelligently analyzes and improves edges where you paint
  • Feather mode: Softens edge transition
  • Add mode: Forces areas to be included in selection
  • Remove mode: Forces areas to be excluded from selection
  • Start with Refine mode selected
  • Adjust Brush Size slider to match hair strand thickness (10-50 pixels typically)
  • Slowly drag brush along hair edges where background shows through
  • What happens: Brush recalculates selection along those edges, capturing individual strands based on color/luminance analysis
  • Critical technique: Short strokes work better than long continuous strokes—let tool process each stroke before continuing

Step 6: Fine-Tune with Sliders (Optional)

  • Most selection refinement happens through brushing, but sliders provide global adjustments:
  • Border Width slider: Defines how wide an edge area the tool analyzes (5-50 pixels)—increase for very fuzzy hair
  • Smooth slider: Reduces jagged edges—use sparingly as it can eliminate fine detail
  • Feather slider: Softens transition—typically 0.5-2 pixels for natural edges
  • Expand Border slider: Grows or shrinks overall selection—useful for eliminating or adding consistent fringe
  • Adjust experimentally: Move sliders, observe effect, undo if worse (Ctrl+Z works inside Refine Brush dialog)

Completing the Selection

Step 7: Output Refined Selection

  • When satisfied with preview, locate Output drop-down at dialog bottom
  • Choose output method based on your needs:
  • Selection: Returns you to image with refined selection active (marching ants)—use if you want to continue editing selection manually
  • Mask: Creates mask on current layer from selection—background becomes transparent
  • New Layer: Creates new layer with selected subject, background transparent, original layer preserved beneath
  • New Mask Layer: Creates mask group (three layers)—most flexible option
  • Select New Layer for most situations
  • Click OK to apply
  • Result: Subject appears on new layer with background removed, original layer intact beneath

Background Manipulation

Step 8A: Replace Background

  • With subject on transparent layer (checkerboard visible), insert new background:
  • File > Open to open background image in separate document
  • Edit > Copy the background
  • Return to subject document, Edit > Paste as New Layer
  • In Layers palette, drag pasted background layer BENEATH subject layer
  • Position/resize using Pick Tool (press K)

Step 8B: Blur Original Background

  • Before running Refine Brush, duplicate your image layer: Layers > Duplicate
  • Keep original layer visible beneath masked subject layer
  • Click original background layer to select it
  • Adjust > Blur > Gaussian Blur, set Radius 15-40 pixels
  • Click OK
  • Result: Sharp subject against blurred background

Step 8C: Darken/Desaturate Background

  • Click original background layer
  • Adjust > Hue and Saturation > Colorize, check Colorize, move Saturation to 0 for grayscale
  • Adjust > Brightness and Contrast > Brightness/Contrast, move Brightness slider left to darken
  • Subject layer above remains colorful and bright against subdued background

 

Photoshop’s implementation represents the definitive channel-based selection workflow, offering maximum control and the finest results when properly executed.

Analyzing Your Image for Channel Selection

Step 1: Open the Channels Panel

  • Navigate to Window > Channels (or click the Channels tab beside Layers if already visible)
  • What this does: Displays the separate Red, Green, and Blue channels comprising your image, plus the RGB composite showing all combined
  • Why necessary: You must identify which single channel offers the greatest luminance contrast between subject and background—this channel becomes your selection foundation

Step 2: Evaluate Each Channel Individually

  • Click the Red channel thumbnail—the entire image shifts to grayscale showing only red information
  • Click Green channel, then Blue channel, examining each carefully
  • Look specifically at the hair edges: which channel shows the lightest hair against the darkest background (or vice versa)?
  • Critical observation: Focus ONLY on the hair/background boundary, ignoring how the subject’s body appears—facial detail doesn’t matter here
  • Common patterns: Blue channel often works best for warm-toned subjects against cool backgrounds; Red channel excels for cool-toned subjects against warm backgrounds

Example decision-making: If photographing a person with brown hair against a blue sky, the Blue channel typically shows maximum contrast—the sky appears dark gray and hair appears light gray. This dramatic separation makes selection possible.

Creating Your Working Channel

Step 3: Duplicate the Best-Contrast Channel

  • Click once on your chosen channel (e.g., Blue) to select it
  • Drag this channel down to the New Channel button (page icon with folded corner at panel bottom), or right-click and select Duplicate Channel
  • What this does: Creates an independent copy named “Blue copy” or similar, preserving the original untouched
  • Why necessary: You’ll heavily modify this channel—working on a duplicate protects your original image data and allows restarting if needed

Step 4: Maximize Contrast with Levels

  • Ensure your duplicated channel remains selected (highlighted in Channels panel)
  • Press Ctrl+L (Windows) or Cmd+L (Mac) to open Levels dialog
  • What this does: Provides sliders controlling the brightness distribution in your channel
  • Observe the histogram (mountain-shaped graph) showing tone distribution
  • Drag the left black slider rightward until it reaches the histogram’s left edge—this intensifies shadows
  • Drag the right white slider leftward until it reaches the histogram’s right edge—this brightens highlights
  • Critical technique: Move sliders aggressively at first to see maximum effect, then back off slightly if hair detail begins disappearing
  • Goal: Achieve stark contrast—ideally pure white hair against pure black background (or vice versa), maintaining visible individual hair strands
  • Click OK when satisfied

Why this works: The Levels adjustment pushes midtones toward pure black or pure white, eliminating gray ambiguity that confuses selections. You’re essentially creating a “map” where white areas mean “select this” and black areas mean “don’t select this.”

Refining Your Channel Selection Map

Step 5: Paint the Subject Completely Black

  • Press B to activate the Brush Tool
  • Press D to reset foreground/background colors (black foreground, white background)
  • In the toolbar or Tool Options, set brush Hardness to 100% for crisp edges on the body
  • Set Opacity to 100% for complete coverage
  • Click-drag to paint the entire subject’s body, face, clothing—everything EXCEPT the hair—completely black
  • Critical boundary: Paint right up to where hair meets the head/shoulders, but avoid painting over any hair strands including those with visible background showing through
  • What this does: Designates the solid body areas as definitely part of your selection
  • Why necessary: Your contrast enhancement probably left the body gray rather than pure black/white—manual painting ensures these areas select completely

Step 6: Clean the Background with Dodge Tool

  • Press O to activate the Dodge Tool (lightens areas)
  • In Tool Options, set Range to Highlights and Exposure to 20-30%
  • Set brush size to match hair strand thickness (use [ and ] keys to resize)
  • What this does: Lightens gray areas in the background to pure white without affecting black areas (your subject)
  • Carefully paint over background areas visible between hair strands—gaps where sky/background shows through curls
  • Critical technique: Work systematically around all hair edges, zooming to 100% or 200% magnification (Ctrl/Cmd + Plus)
  • Watch for gray fog in the background—dodge these areas until pure white
  • Why necessary: Gray areas in the background will partially select, causing fringing in your final result; pure white ensures complete non-selection

Alternative Step 6: Use Brush with Overlay Mode

  • If Dodge Tool proves too aggressive, select Brush Tool (B)
  • Set foreground color to White (press D then X to swap colors)
  • In Tool Options, change Brush Mode from Normal to Overlay
  • Set Opacity to 50-70%
  • Paint over background areas—Overlay mode lightens light areas while preserving dark areas, providing more control
  • Advantage: Less likely to accidentally lighten the subject’s black areas
Converting Channel to Selection

Step 7: Load Channel as Selection

  • Hold Ctrl (Windows) or Cmd (Mac) and click directly on your “Blue copy” channel thumbnail (the gray rectangle)
  • What this does: Photoshop reads the channel’s brightness information as selection intensity—white areas become fully selected, black areas unselected, gray areas partially selected based on brightness
  • Marching ants appear, though they won’t accurately show the soft edges
  • Expected result: If you carefully painted subject black and background white, the background should be selected while subject isn’t
  • Visual check: The marching ants should encircle your subject

Step 8: Invert the Selection

  • Press Ctrl+Shift+I (Windows) or Cmd+Shift+I (Mac), or choose Select > Inverse
  • What this does: Flips the selection inside-out—now the subject is selected, background isn’t
  • Why necessary: Channels select light areas by default; since we painted background white (light), it selected background; inverting makes the subject (black) selected instead
  • Confirmation: Marching ants should now surround the background rather than subject
Applying Selection as Layer Mask

Step 9: Return to Layers and Create Mask

  • Click the RGB channel at the top of Channels panel (or simply switch to Layers panel)
  • What this does: Returns you to normal color view of your image
  • The selection remains active (marching ants persist)
  • In Layers panel, ensure your image layer is selected (highlighted in blue)
  • Click the Add Layer Mask button (rectangle with circle inside, at panel bottom)
  • What this does: Creates a mask from your selection—black areas hide (background disappears), white areas show (subject remains), gray areas display partially based on gray intensity
  • Result: Your subject appears isolated with intricate hair detail preserved

Step 10: Check and Refine Mask

  • Add a contrasting temporary background layer: click the Create new layer button (folded page icon), drag it BELOW your subject layer
  • Fill it with a contrasting color: Edit > Fill > Color, choose bright magenta or green
  • What this does: Makes any selection errors immediately visible as colored halos or missing areas
  • Zoom to 100% and examine all hair edges carefully
  • Refining technique: Click the mask thumbnail (black and white rectangle in Layers panel) to ensure it’s selected (white border appears)
  • Press B for Brush Tool, set to Normal mode, 100% opacity, soft edge
  • Paint with white on the mask to reveal more of the subject (if hair strands disappeared)
  • Paint with black on the mask to hide more (if background fringe shows)
  • Critical concept: You’re editing the mask, not the image—white reveals, black conceals
Background Replacement or Adjustment

Step 11A: Replace Background (Clean Extraction)

  • With selection successfully masked, your subject exists on transparent background (indicated by gray/white checkerboard if you delete the temporary color layer)
  • File > Place Embedded to import a new background image, or
  • Create a new layer below subject layer, fill with solid color (Edit > Fill), or
  • Ctrl/Cmd + V to paste another image as new layer, then drag it below subject layer in Layers panel
  • Result: Subject composited onto entirely new background with maintained hair detail

Step 11B: Blur Existing Background (Subject Emphasis)

  • Instead of replacing background, you can blur it to create shallow depth-of-field effect
  • Invert the mask: with mask thumbnail selected, press Ctrl+I / Cmd+I
  • What this does: Now background is showing, subject is hidden (reversed)
  • Apply blur: Filter > Blur > Gaussian Blur, set Radius to 8-25 pixels depending on image resolution
  • Why effective: Blurred background draws all attention to sharply-defined subject
  • Invert mask again (Ctrl+I / Cmd+I) to restore subject visibility
  • Your subject now appears sharp against artistically blurred background

Step 11C: Darken/Desaturate Background (Dramatic Effect)

  • Create a Levels adjustment layer (Layer > New Adjustment Layer > Levels)
  • In the adjustment layer’s mask (automatically created as white), paint black over the subject using a large soft brush
  • What this does: Adjustment affects only unmasked areas—the background
  • In Levels dialog, drag middle gray slider right to darken background significantly
  • Create a Hue/Saturation adjustment layer (Layer > New Adjustment Layer > Hue/Saturation)
  • Again paint black over subject in the adjustment layer’s mask
  • Drag Saturation slider left to -50 or -100, converting background to grayscale or muted tones
  • Result: Subject retains full color and brightness, dramatic against subdued background

Affinity Photo: Professional Channel Method Alternative

Affinity Photo provides a complete channel-based workflow nearly identical to Photoshop’s, with a few interface variations. The underlying principle remains identical: find high-contrast channel, enhance it, convert to selection.

Channel Analysis and Duplication

Step 1: Access Channels Panel

  • Navigate to View > Studio > Channels or click Channels in right-side panel dock
  • What this shows: Four channel thumbnails—RGB composite plus individual Red, Green, Blue channels
  • Why needed: Identify which single channel provides maximum subject/background contrast

Step 2: Identify Optimal Channel

  • Click each channel thumbnail (Red, Green, Blue) in sequence
  • Image temporarily displays in grayscale showing only that channel’s information
  • Critical observation: Which channel renders hair lightest and background darkest (or vice versa)?
  • Note this channel—you’ll duplicate it shortly
  • Click RGB to return to full color view

Step 3: Duplicate High-Contrast Channel

  • Right-click your chosen channel (e.g., Blue) and select Duplicate
  • What this does: Creates independent copy named “Blue Copy” or similar
  • The new channel appears at the panel bottom
  • Click this new copied channel to make it active (highlighted)
  • Why necessary: You’ll destructively edit this channel—duplication preserves the original

Contrast Enhancement and Subject Isolation

Step 4: Apply Levels Adjustment

  • Ensure your copied channel remains selected and visible (image appears grayscale)
  • Navigate to Layer > New Adjustment > Levels (yes, this works on channels too)
  • In Levels dialog, observe the histogram showing tone distribution
  • Drag black input slider (left) rightward until it meets the histogram’s left edge
  • Drag white input slider (right) leftward until it meets the histogram’s right edge
  • What this does: Stretches contrast aggressively, pushing midtones toward pure black or pure white
  • Goal: Achieve maximum separation—ideally pure black background, pure white hair (or reversed)
  • If hair detail begins disappearing, reduce adjustment slightly
  • Click Apply or OK when satisfied
  • Merge adjustment: Right-click the adjustment layer and select Merge Down to bake changes into the channel permanently

Step 5: Paint Subject Area Black

  • With channel still selected, activate Paint Brush Tool (press B)
  • Set foreground color to pure Black (click color swatch, set RGB to 0,0,0)
  • Set brush Hardness to 100% in Tool Options for clean edges on body areas
  • Set Opacity to 100% for complete coverage
  • Flow should be 100% as well for solid painting
  • Zoom in to 100-200% magnification for precision (Ctrl/Cmd + Plus)
  • Carefully paint over the subject’s entire body, face, clothes, hands—everything EXCEPT hair areas
  • Critical boundary: Paint up to where hair strands begin, but avoid covering any hair or gaps in hair
  • What this achieves: Designates solid subject areas as definitely-to-be-selected zones

Step 6: Clean Background Areas

  • Switch foreground color to pure White (click color swatch, set RGB to 255,255,255)
  • Change brush mode to Overlay in Tool Options (dropdown at top of context toolbar)
  • Reduce brush Hardness to 0% (soft edge) for blending with existing tones
  • Set Opacity to 60-80% for controlled application
  • Paint over background areas visible between hair strands—sky showing through curls, gaps at edges
  • What Overlay mode does: Lightens light areas while preserving dark areas—your black subject stays black while gray background lightens to white
  • Critical technique: Zoom in and work methodically around all hair edges, eliminating gray fog
  • If you accidentally lighten subject areas, switch to Brush Tool, set mode to Normal, paint with black to correct

Converting Channel to Mask

Step 7: Load Channel as Selection

  • Hold Ctrl (Windows) or Cmd (Mac)
  • Click directly on your copied channel thumbnail (the small gray rectangle)
  • What happens: “Marching ants” selection appears based on channel brightness—white areas selected, black areas unselected
  • Expected result: If you painted subject black and background white, the background is currently selected
  • Visual confirmation: Ants encircle your subject

Step 8: Invert Selection

  • Press Ctrl+Shift+I (Windows) or Cmd+Shift+I (Mac)
  • Or navigate Select > Invert
  • What this does: Reverses selection—now subject is selected, background is not
  • Marching ants should now surround the background rather than subject

Step 9: Create Mask from Selection

  • Click the RGB channel at top of Channels panel to return to color view
  • Switch to Layers panel
  • Ensure your image layer is selected (highlighted)
  • With selection still active, click the Mask Layer button (rectangle with circle icon at Layers panel bottom)
  • Alternative method: Right-click layer and choose Mask Layer > Layer from Selection
  • What this creates: Layer mask derived from your selection—subject visible with full hair detail, background transparent
  • Result visible: Background converts to checkerboard pattern (transparency indicator); subject remains with intricate edge detail

Verification and Refinement

Step 10: Add Temporary Background for Edge Checking

  • Click Layer > New Layer (or click folded-page icon at bottom of Layers panel)
  • Drag this new layer BELOW your masked subject layer
  • Click Edit > Fill and choose a bright contrasting color (magenta, green, orange)
  • What this does: Provides solid color backdrop making any masking errors immediately visible
  • Zoom to 100-200% and examine hair edges systematically
  • Look for unwanted color halos, missing hair strands, or transparency where subject should be solid

Step 11: Refine Mask with Brush

  • In Layers panel, click the mask thumbnail (black and white rectangle beside layer thumbnail) to select mask for editing
  • Activate Paint Brush Tool (B)
  • Set to Normal mode, 100% opacity, soft-edged brush
  • Paint with white on mask to reveal more subject (if hair disappeared)
  • Paint with black on mask to hide more (if background fringe remains visible)
  • Zoom technique: Use Ctrl/Cmd + mouse wheel to zoom in/out rapidly while refining
  • Bracket keys ([ and ]) adjust brush size instantly
  • Work patiently around problematic edges—this fine-tuning makes the difference between amateur and professional results

Background Manipulation Options

Step 12A: Replace Background Completely

  • Your masked subject now exists on transparent background (checkerboard visible when you delete temporary color layer)
  • Import new background: File > Place, select background image, position beneath subject layer
  • Or create solid color background: new layer beneath subject, Edit > Fill, choose color
  • Or paste from clipboard: Ctrl/Cmd+V, drag resulting layer beneath subject
  • Result: Subject seamlessly composited with maintained hair strand detail

Step 12B: Apply Gaussian Blur to Original Background

  • This technique keeps original background but blurs it for depth-of-field effect
  • Cannot directly blur a masked layer, so duplicate background first
  • Right-click your original background layer (before selection) and Duplicate
  • Click this duplicate to select it
  • Filters > Blur > Gaussian Blur
  • Set Radius to 10-30 pixels depending on desired effect and image size
  • Click Apply
  • Create mask on blurred layer: Click the Mask Layer button
  • Invert mask: Click mask thumbnail to select it, then Edit > Invert (Ctrl/Cmd+I)
  • Use Paint Brush with soft edge and paint with white on this mask over the subject area
  • Result: Subject remains sharp against softly blurred background, mimicking shallow depth-of-field

Step 12C: Darken and Desaturate Background

  • Create HSL adjustment layer (Layer > New Adjustment > HSL)
  • The adjustment affects entire image initially
  • Move Saturation slider left to -60 to -100 to remove background color
  • Move Lightness slider left to -20 to -40 to darken background
  • In adjustment layer’s mask (white by default), use Paint Brush Tool with black to paint over subject area
  • What this achieves: Adjustment affects only background (white mask areas), subject remains unchanged (black mask areas)
  • Result: Vibrant, full-color subject dramatically contrasts against muted, darkened background

Adobe Photoshop Elements: Simplified Channel Access

Photoshop Elements provides channel-based selection capability, though the interface is more hidden than Photoshop’s dedicated panel. The methodology remains identical—leverage channel contrast for superior selections.

Accessing Hidden Channels

Step 1: Open Image and Expert Mode

  • Launch Photoshop Elements and click Photo Editor from home screen
  • Ensure you’re in Expert mode (click Expert tab at top if not)
  • Open your image: File > Open, navigate to file, click Open
  • Why Expert mode: Simplified modes (Quick, Guided) don’t provide channel access

Step 2: Display Channels via Preferences Workaround

  • Photoshop Elements doesn’t show Channels panel by default—it’s intentionally hidden
  • Access channels indirectly: Go to Enhance > Adjust Color > Remove Color Cast
  • Click Cancel immediately (we don’t want this adjustment, just opened it to access menus)
  • Alternative method: Create a Levels adjustment: Enhance > Adjust Lighting > Levels (Ctrl/Cmd+L)
  • In Levels dialog, observe the Channel dropdown at top (shows “RGB” by default)
  • What this reveals: Click dropdown to see Red, Green, Blue channels listed
  • Critical limitation: Elements doesn’t allow clicking channels to view them in isolation—you must work through this dropdown

Step 3: Identify Best Channel Using Levels Preview

  • In Levels dialog (already open), click Channel dropdown and select Red
  • Observe how the image preview changes (or look at the histogram shape)
  • Click dropdown again, select Green, observe
  • Click dropdown again, select Blue, observe
  • Decision criteria: Note which channel shows the steepest histogram spread near left (blacks) and right (whites) edges—this indicates strong contrast
  • Alternatively: Note which channel makes hair appear most distinctly different from background in your mind’s eye based on histogram
  • Remember this channel—you’ll enhance it
  • Click Cancel to close Levels for now

Manual Channel Duplication via Desaturation

Step 4: Create Single-Channel Version

  • Photoshop Elements doesn’t allow direct channel duplication like Photoshop
  • Workaround: We’ll convert the image to grayscale using only the best channel’s data
  • Go to Image > Mode > Grayscale
  • A dialog asks “Discard color information?” — click Cancel (we don’t want automatic conversion)
  • Alternative approach: Layer > Duplicate Layer to create copy of your image
  • Click the duplicate layer to select it
  • Go to Enhance > Adjust Color > Remove Color (Shift+Ctrl/Cmd+U)
  • What this does: Desaturates to grayscale, but using all channel information equally—not ideal
  • Better Elements approach: Use Camera Raw filter if available
  • Or accept limitation: Proceed with Remove Color, acknowledging results won’t match full Photoshop’s precision

Reality check: Photoshop Elements’ channel limitations make pure channel-based selection difficult. Elements users get better results using the Refine Selection Brush (see alternative method below) or upgrading to full Photoshop. That said, we can approximate channel method with workarounds.

Alternative: Elements Refine Selection Brush Method

Given Elements’ channel limitations, this alternative provides excellent hair selection without full channel access:

Alternative Step 1: Make Initial Selection with Quick Selection Tool

  • Click the Quick Selection Tool from toolbox (magic wand with brush, or press A)
  • In Tool Options, set brush size to moderate (50-100 pixels for average image)
  • Click-drag across your subject repeatedly until most of the body and hair area is selected (marching ants appear)
  • Don’t worry about precision yet—rough selection suffices
  • If tool selects too much background, hold Alt (Windows) or Option (Mac) while clicking to subtract areas

Alternative Step 2: Activate Refine Selection Brush

  • With selection active, click Refine Selection Brush in toolbox (below Quick Selection Tool, or press Arepeatedly to cycle)
  • What this tool does: Analyzes edges intelligently to improve selection based on where you paint
  • Tool Options show concentric circle cursor preview

Alternative Step 3: Refine Edge Mode for Hair

  • Place cursor directly on hair edges where background shows through strands
  • The cursor has two circles: inner circle (dark) and outer circle (light gray)
  • Inner circle: Definitely select this area
  • Outer circle: Search zone where tool analyzes and refines
  • Click-hold and drag slowly along hair edges
  • What happens: Tool recalculates selection in that area, capturing individual strands based on color/luminance differences
  • Critical technique: Work in short strokes along edges, not long continuous strokes
  • For gaps in hair (sky showing through curls), click-hold directly on the gap with cursor centered on hair, not gap

Alternative Step 4: Adjust Selection Edge Properties

  • In Tool Options, adjust Selection Edge slider (1-40 range)
  • Lower values (1-10): Sharp edges, good for clean backgrounds and short hair
  • Higher values (20-40): Soft edges, better for long wispy hair and complex backgrounds
  • Adjust Size slider to change brush dimensions (match to hair strand thickness)
  • Mode settings: Choose Add to grow selection, Subtract to shrink it

Alternative Step 5: View Against Different Backgrounds

  • Still in Refine Selection Brush mode, Tool Options show View drop-down
  • Select Overlay to see selection as red overlay (unselected areas red, selected areas clear)
  • Select Black to preview subject on black background
  • Select White to preview subject on white background
  • Why important: Different background colors reveal different edge problems—fringing visible on black might not show on white
  • Toggle between views while refining to catch all issues

Alternative Step 6: Finalize Selection as Mask

  • When satisfied with refinement, switch to any other tool (e.g., press V for Move Tool) to commit the selection
  • Layer > Layer Mask > Reveal Selection creates mask from your refined selection
  • Or simply copy-paste selection to new layer: Ctrl/Cmd+J
  • Background disappears (transparent checkerboard appears behind subject)

Background Adjustment in Elements

Step 7A: Blur Background Behind Subject (Elements Method)

  • Since Elements doesn’t support non-destructive masking as robustly, use workaround:
  • With subject on separate layer (transparent background), add new layer beneath
  • Or if subject still on original background layer, make copy: Layer > Duplicate Layer
  • Hide the sharp subject layer (click eye icon)
  • Click background layer to select it
  • Filter > Blur > Gaussian Blur, set Radius 15-30 pixels
  • Click OK to apply
  • Unhide subject layer (click eye icon space)—subject now appears sharp against blurred background

Step 7B: Darken/Desaturate Background

  • Elements lacks adjustment layers with masks, so requires manual workaround:
  • Duplicate background layer: Layer > Duplicate Layer
  • Go to Enhance > Adjust Color > Remove Color to desaturate duplicate
  • Go to Enhance > Adjust Lighting > Brightness/Contrast, move Brightness slider left to darken
  • Click OK
  • Add layer mask: Layer > Layer Mask > Reveal All
  • Select Brush Tool (B), set foreground to black, paint over subject in mask
  • Result: Subject shows through in full color, darkened desaturated background surrounds them

Traditional Channel Method in GIMP

Step 1: Open Channels Dialog

  • Launch GIMP and open your image: File > Open, navigate to image file
  • Go to Windows > Dockable Dialogs > Channels (or press Ctrl+Shift+C if no default)
  • What appears: Channels dialog, typically docked on right side beside Layers
  • What you see: Four channel thumbnails—Red, Green, Blue, plus Alpha (transparency)
  • Why needed: Identify which RGB channel shows maximum hair/background contrast

Step 2: Identify Optimal Channel

  • Click Red channel thumbnail (image becomes grayscale showing only red information)
  • The eye icon beside Red activates, others deactivate
  • Observe the hair-to-background contrast in this view
  • Click Green channel thumbnail, then Blue channel thumbnail, evaluating each
  • Critical decision: Which channel renders hair most distinctly separated from background?
  • Mental note: Remember this channel—you’ll duplicate it
  • Click RGB at top (or click eye icons on all three channels) to restore color view

Step 3: Duplicate Best-Contrast Channel

  • Right-click on your chosen channel (e.g., Blue)
  • Select Duplicate Channel from context menu
  • What appears: New channel named “Blue copy” appears at dialog bottom
  • Click this new channel to make it active (highlighted)
  • GIMP automatically shows only this channel (image converts to grayscale)
  • Why duplicate: You’ll destructively modify this channel; duplication preserves originals

Contrast Maximization and Selection Refinement

Step 4: Enhance Channel Contrast with Levels

  • With duplicate channel selected and visible (should appear grayscale)
  • Navigate to Colors > Levels (or press Ctrl+L)
  • What appears: Levels dialog with histogram showing tone distribution
  • Locate three Input Levels triangular sliders below histogram
  • Drag left black triangle rightward until it reaches left edge of histogram mountain
  • Drag right white triangle leftward until it reaches right edge of histogram mountain
  • What this does: Expands contrast aggressively, pushing midtones toward pure black or white
  • Goal: Maximum separation—ideally stark white hair against pure black background (or reversed)
  • If hair strands begin disappearing, reduce adjustment by dragging sliders back slightly
  • Click OK when satisfied
  • Result: Channel now displays extremely high contrast version of original

Step 5: Paint Subject Solid Black

  • Ensure your channel copy remains selected in Channels dialog
  • Click Toolbox > Paintbrush Tool (P) to activate brush
  • Set foreground color to pure black: click foreground color square in toolbox, enter 000000 in HTML notation field
  • In Tool Options (usually docked left), set Opacity to 100, Hardness to 100
  • Set Size to comfortable value for painting larger areas (50-150 pixels depending on image size)
  • Zoom to 100-200% magnification: View > Zoom > 1:1 (or press 1 key)
  • Carefully paint over subject’s entire body, face, hands, clothing—everything EXCEPT hair
  • Critical boundary: Paint up to hair roots, but don’t cover any hair strands or gaps where background shows through hair
  • What this achieves: Designates solid subject areas as definitely-to-be-selected (black = high selection when inverted)

Step 6: Paint Background Solid White

  • Switch foreground color to pure white: Click foreground color square, enter FFFFFF in HTML notation
  • Alternative: Press X to swap foreground/background colors (assuming background was white)
  • Paint over all background areas, especially gaps visible between hair strands
  • Critical zones: Sky showing through curls, background visible at hair edges
  • Zoom in (scroll wheel or View > Zoom) to work at strand level
  • What this achieves: Designates background as definitely-not-to-be-selected (white = low selection)
  • Tricky areas: For semi-transparent wisps where hair and background blend, leave them gray—GIMP interprets gray as partial selection
  • Work methodically around entire hair perimeter until background is completely white, subject completely black, with gray only at very fine edge transitions

Loading Channel as Selection

Step 7: Convert Channel to Selection

  • In Channels dialog, locate your modified copy channel (Blue copy, etc.)
  • Right-click this channel thumbnail
  • Select Channel to Selection from context menu
  • What happens: “Marching ants” selection appears based on channel’s brightness values
  • Marching ants behavior: They indicate 50% selection threshold—you won’t see edges of partial selections (gray areas)
  • Expected result: If you painted background white and subject black, the background is currently selected (white = selected, black = unselected)

Step 8: Invert Selection for Subject

  • Go to Select > Invert (or press Ctrl+I)
  • What this does: Reverses selection—now subject is selected (black channel areas), background is not (white channel areas)
  • Confirmation: Marching ants should now encircle background rather than subject

Step 9: Return to Layer and Create Mask

  • In Channels dialog, click the eye icon next to RGB (at top) to make color visible again
  • Or simply switch to Layers dialog (beside Channels)
  • Your selection remains active (marching ants persist across dialogs)
  • In Layers dialog, right-click your image layer
  • Select Add Layer Mask > Selection from context menu
  • What this creates: Layer mask derived from active selection—subject visible, background transparent
  • Result: Background converts to gray/white checkerboard (GIMP’s transparency indicator), subject remains with fine hair detail intact

Alternative Method: GIMP Foreground Select Tool

GIMP uniquely offers the Foreground Select tool—a specialized selection approach particularly effective for organic subjects against complex backgrounds.

Alternative Step 1: Make Rough Initial Selection

  • Click Tools > Selection Tools > Foreground Select (or press F if keyboard shortcuts enabled)
  • What this tool does: Two-stage selection process—first rough outline, then refinement by painting foreground colors
  • Click to place first point on edge of subject
  • Click around subject perimeter, placing points every inch or two
  • Don’t worry about precision around hair—stay slightly inside hair boundary
  • Close the selection by clicking first point again
  • Result: Area outside rough outline darkens (blue overlay by default), area inside remains bright

Alternative Step 2: Paint Foreground Indicator Strokes

  • Tool automatically switches to painting mode
  • In Tool Options, adjust Stroke width to comfortable size (20-50 pixels initially)
  • Paint continuous strokes THROUGH the subject, covering various colors
  • Critical concept: You’re not painting selection boundaries—you’re showing GIMP what colors belong to foreground
  • Paint through hair using multiple strokes of different colors
  • Paint through face, clothes, hands—every distinct color region
  • What GIMP does: Analyzes painted colors, then extends selection to all pixels matching those colors within the rough boundary

Alternative Step 3: Refine Using Draw Modes

  • Tool Options show three Draw modes: Draw foreground, Draw background, Draw unknown
  • Select Draw foreground to paint areas that should definitely be selected
  • Select Draw background to paint areas that should definitely NOT be selected
  • Select Draw unknown to refine ambiguous edges
  • Toggle between modes, refining the selection until preview looks accurate
  • For complex hair: Use small brush with Draw foreground mode, painting individual strands

Alternative Step 4: Finalize Selection

  • Press Enter or click Select button in Tool Options
  • What happens: Blue overlay disappears, marching ants selection appears around subject
  • Go to Layer > Mask > Add Layer Mask > Selection
  • Subject is now masked with background removed

Background Manipulation

Step 10A: Replace Background

  • With masked subject layer, background shows as checkerboard (transparency)
  • File > Open as Layers to import new background image beneath subject
  • Or create new layer beneath subject (Layer > New Layer), fill with color (Edit > Fill with FG Color)
  • Result: Subject composited onto new background

Step 10B: Blur Original Background

  • This requires retaining original background layer
  • Before creating mask, duplicate image layer: Layer > Duplicate Layer
  • Work on top copy (masked subject), leave bottom layer intact (original background)
  • Click original background layer to select it
  • Filters > Blur > Gaussian Blur, set Radius 10-30 pixels
  • Click OK
  • Result: Subject sharp, background blurred

Step 10C: Darken and Desaturate Background

  • With original background layer selected
  • Colors > Desaturate > Desaturate to convert background to grayscale
  • Colors > Brightness-Contrast, move Brightness slider left to darken
  • Masked subject layer above shows in full color against darkened grayscale background

Adobe Lightroom Classic: Background Adjustment via Masking

Important limitation: Lightroom cannot extract subjects, replace backgrounds, or create transparency. It’s a non-destructive RAW processor operating on the original file. However, Lightroom’s AI masking creates sophisticated subject/background separation for differential adjustments—ideal for de-emphasizing backgrounds while maintaining subject pop.

Creating Subject and Background Masks

Step 1: Open Image in Develop Module

  • Import your image into Lightroom: File > Import Photos and Video
  • Select image in Library Grid view
  • Press D to enter Develop module
  • What this provides: Access to adjustment sliders and masking tools

Step 2: Create Subject Mask

  • Locate Masking button below Histogram (circular icon, or press Shift+W)
  • Click Masking button to open Masking panel
  • Click Create New Mask (+ icon)
  • Select Select Subject from dropdown menu
  • What happens: Lightroom’s AI analyzes image, automatically detecting and selecting primary human subject
  • Red overlay appears showing selected areas (overlay intensity adjustable via toolbar)
  • Result: “Subject 1” mask appears in Masks list
  • Why useful: This mask allows adjusting only the subject, leaving background untouched

Step 3: Create Background Mask

  • In Masking panel, click Create New Mask (+) again
  • Select Select Background from dropdown
  • What happens: AI automatically selects everything EXCEPT the subject
  • Red overlay shows background areas selected
  • Result: “Background 1” mask appears in Masks list
  • Alternative approach: Create Subject mask, then invert it: Right-click Subject mask, choose Invert—this creates background mask from subject
  • Why useful: Allows adjusting only background without affecting subject

De-Emphasizing Background with Selective Adjustments

Step 4: Reduce Background Sharpness (Blur Approximation)

  • In Masks panel, click Background 1 mask to select it (highlighted)
  • Adjustment sliders (right side of Develop module) now affect ONLY masked background
  • Locate Sharpening slider (in Detail panel—you may need to expand it)
  • Wait—Sharpening doesn’t work in masks! Lightroom limitation.
  • Workaround using Texture and Clarity:
  • Move Texture slider significantly to LEFT (around -50 to -100)—this reduces micro-contrast, creating soft appearance
  • Move Clarity slider to LEFT (around -30 to -60)—this reduces midtone contrast, approximating blur
  • What these do: Combined, Texture and Clarity reductions create soft, de-emphasized background without actual blur filter
  • Result: Background appears softer, less detailed, drawing attention to sharp subject

Step 5: Desaturate Background

  • With Background mask still selected
  • Move Saturation slider to LEFT (around -50 to -100 depending on desired effect)
  • What this does: Removes color from background, converting toward grayscale
  • Result: Muted, black-and-white background makes colorful subject dramatically pop
  • Alternative: Move Vibrance slider left (more natural desaturation, affects weaker colors more than strong ones)

Step 6: Darken Background

  • With Background mask still selected
  • Move Exposure slider to LEFT (around -0.50 to -1.50 stops)—this darkens overall
  • And/or move Shadows slider to LEFT (around -30 to -60)—this specifically darkens shadow areas
  • And/or move Blacks slider to LEFT (around -30 to -60)—this deepens darkest tones
  • What these do: Combined, they dramatically darken background, creating high-contrast separation from subject
  • Critical balance: Don’t darken so much that background becomes pure black blob—maintain some detail/gradation

Step 7: Reduce Background Contrast

  • With Background mask still selected
  • Move Contrast slider to LEFT (around -20 to -50)
  • What this does: Reduces tonal range in background, flattening it
  • Result: Background becomes less dynamic, less attention-grabbing, further emphasizing subject
  • Combines with darkness: Low-contrast dark background = moody, dramatic effect

Enhancing Subject for Maximum Separation

Step 8: Boost Subject Clarity

  • In Masks panel, click Subject 1 mask to select it
  • Move Clarity slider to RIGHT (around +20 to +50)
  • What this does: Increases midtone contrast in subject only, making them pop with added dimension
  • Result: Subject appears more defined, three-dimensional against flattened background

Step 9: Brighten Subject (Optional)

  • With Subject mask still selected
  • Move Exposure slider to RIGHT (around +0.30 to +0.70 stops) if subject appears too dark after background darkening
  • What this does: Compensates for visual perception—humans perceive darker backgrounds as making subjects look darker by contrast
  • Result: Brighter subject against darker background = dramatic chiaroscuro effect

Step 10: Boost Subject Saturation (Optional)

  • With Subject mask still selected
  • Move Vibrance slider to RIGHT (around +20 to +50) for natural color boost
  • Or move Saturation slider to RIGHT (around +10 to +30) for stronger color intensification
  • What this does: Makes subject’s colors more vivid
  • Result: Maximum color contrast between vibrant subject and muted background

Refining Mask Boundaries

Step 11: Review and Adjust Mask Edges

  • Click Show Overlay checkbox (or press O) to toggle red mask overlay visibility on/off
  • Press Shift+O to cycle overlay color (red, green, white, black) for better visibility against your image
  • Examine mask edges critically—AI isn’t perfect
  • If mask includes unwanted areas or excludes subject parts:
  • Click mask in Masks panel to select it
  • Click Add or Subtract button
  • Choose Brush tool
  • Manually paint adjustments with soft-edged brush (adjust Size and Feather in brush settings)
  • Paint with Add selected to include more areas in mask
  • Paint with Subtract selected to remove areas from mask

Step 12: Fine-Tune Mask Density

  • In Masks panel, each mask has Amount slider
  • This controls overall strength of mask (0% = no effect, 100% = full effect)
  • If background adjustments appear too aggressive, reduce Background mask Amount to 70-80%
  • If subject enhancements insufficient, increase Subject mask Amount to 110-120% (yes, over 100% is possible)

Exporting Adjusted Image

Step 13: Export Final Result

  • Press G to return to Library module
  • Select your adjusted image
  • Go to File > Export
  • Set Export Location to desired folder
  • Set File Naming convention
  • In File Settings, choose Image Format: JPEG
  • Set Quality slider to 90-100 for maximum quality
  • Set Color Space: sRGB (ensures widest compatibility)
  • Click Export
  • Result: JPEG file with dramatic subject/background separation through localized adjustments
Universal Principles Across All Software

Despite interface differences, certain truths apply to channel-based and advanced selection methods universally:

Image quality determines ceiling: No selection method can extract detail that doesn’t exist. Soft-focus images, motion-blurred hair, or tiny resolution images yield poor results regardless of technique. Start with sharp, high-resolution sources captured against reasonably contrasting backgrounds whenever possible.

Patience and iteration yield mastery: Your first five channel-based selections will take 30-60 minutes each and yield mediocre results. By your twentieth, you’ll complete them in 10 minutes with professional quality. This technique requires investment—the payoff is selection capability that exceeds most AI tools in challenging scenarios.

Contrast is everything: The single most important factor in channel selection success is finding strong contrast in ANY single channel between subject and background. Images with subject and background of similar brightness and color across all channels require different approaches or hybrid methods. Analyze before committing.

Preview on multiple backgrounds: Always check your final masked selection against multiple background colors—black, white, and a mid-tone. Fringing invisible on black becomes glaringly obvious on white, and vice versa. Build background-checking into your workflow rather than discovering problems after delivery.

Layer masks preserve flexibility: Never permanently delete pixels—always use layer masks. Masks allow non-destructive refinement, letting you perfect edges days later without restarting. Additionally, masking enables blending modes and adjustment combinations impossible with destructive cutouts.

Zoom discipline prevents errors: Work at 100% magnification minimum when refining selections, 200% for critical hair areas. What appears acceptable at fit-to-screen view reveals as crude approximation when zoomed. Develop the discipline to zoom habitually—it separates amateur from professional results.

Keyboard shortcuts accelerate workflow: Channel-based selection involves repetitive actions—switching tools, adjusting brush size, toggling view modes, inverting selections. Learning 10-15 essential shortcuts reduces 45-minute tasks to 15 minutes. Invest early in memorization.

Save selection channels for reuse: Most programs allow saving selections as alpha channels (additional channels beyond RGB). When you perfect a difficult selection, save it—you might need to rework the background adjustment later, and reselecting from scratch wastes the previous effort. Think ahead.

Understand your goal before selecting: Different end uses demand different edge qualities. Compositing onto busy photographic backgrounds tolerates slight edge imperfection that would ruin placement on pure white. Billboards viewed from distance allow edge softness unacceptable in magazine close-ups. Define acceptable quality before investing hours in perfection you may not need.

Troubleshooting Common Channel Selection Problems

Problem: Hair appears transparent or “ghosted” in final result

  • Cause: Channel contrast insufficient—hair and background too similar in brightness
  • Solution: Try different channel (green instead of blue), or combine channels using Calculations (Photoshop) or Apply Image (GIMP). Alternatively, consider this image unsuitable for pure channel method—hybrid approach needed

Problem: Subject body/face shows transparent areas or speckles

  • Cause: Incomplete painting of subject area black during channel refinement
  • Solution: Return to channel, paint subject completely black except hair edges. Zoom to 100% and check every pixel of face/body/clothing—any gray = partial transparency

Problem: White or colored “halo” around hair on new background

  • Cause: Fringe pixels containing old background color bleeding into hair edges
  • Solution: In mask, paint with black using 50% opacity soft brush SLIGHTLY into subject along problem edges. This selectively hides fringe pixels. Alternatively, use Decontaminate Colors option (Photoshop Select & Mask) or Matting > Defringe (GIMP Layer menu)

Problem: Selection looks perfect but exports with background anyway

  • Cause: Exporting in format that doesn’t support transparency (JPEG), or mask not applied/inverted correctly
  • Solution: Export as PNG for transparency support, or composite onto new background before exporting JPEG. Verify mask actually hides background by temporarily adding colored layer beneath

Problem: Channel method selects background along with hair

  • Cause: Insufficient contrast enhancement, or background and hair similar brightness in chosen channel
  • Solution: Increase Levels adjustment aggressiveness (move sliders closer to histogram center). Try different channel. Use Dodge tool more extensively to brighten background areas. As last resort, manually paint problem areas with Brush on channel

Problem: Technique works but takes 2+ hours per image

  • Cause: Either insufficient practice or image truly difficult (fuzzy hair on matching-color background)
  • Solution: Practice on easier images first—crisp hair against contrasting backgrounds. Build muscle memory for the workflow. For genuinely difficult images, consider whether result justifies time investment vs. using simpler selection then rebuilding missing hair detail with clone/healing tools

Activity Three - Edit My RAW files

Five RAW files are provided. Download here (209.4MB .ZIP archive) 

Thanks to Robin Dodd, Steven Galvin, Andy Kirby, Simon Major.  Original and derivative works are (C) Copyright 2025 the original Author and provided for training purposes only. 

Do what you can to make them into a competition worthy JPG.

Use any Software you like.  AI Assisted selection methods are allowed, but Generative AI is not (as per Marlow CC rules, all parts of an image must be the Author’s, and yes, I see the irony that you’re editing someone else’s RAW file)

Put the end result into Photoentry as a PDI. Entry closes midnight next Sunday,  16th November.